Region
Sub-Saharan Africa
Income group
Upper middle income
Most populous city
Port Louis

ACCESS DATA BY
ECONOMY OR TOPIC


or
Arbitrating Commercial Disputes Details
This index compares the strength of countries’ arbitration regimes by examining the laws and regulations governing domestic and international arbitrations, as well as the countries’ adherence to specific international conventions.
QuestionAnswer
* Does your national law recognize arbitration as a means of dispute resolution between private parties in commercial transactions? Yes
* Has your country enacted a specific statute on commercial arbitration? Yes
Please list the relevant laws and the years of their adoption International Arbitration Act of 2008
* Please indicate the Web site(s) where the statute(s) can be consulted http://supremecourt.intnet.mu
http://www.gov.mu
Is the statute based on UNCITRAL? Yes
Comment N/A
Are there other codes, statutes or legislative provisions governing commercial arbitration in your country? Yes
Please list the relevant laws and the years of their adoption Code of Civil Procedure;
Arbitration Protocol (Clauses) Act of 1931;
Foreign Arbitration (Awards) Act of 1931.
Please note that the International Arbitration Act does not apply to dome ...morestic arbitration in Mauritius. The Act establishes two distinct and separate regimes for domestic arbitration and international arbitration. Domestic arbitration is governed by the Mauritius Code of Civil Procedure in Articles 1003 to 1028-11.
...less
List web sites http://www.supremecourt.innet.mu
Definition of domestic arbitration Domestic arbitration is defined in Section 2 of the International Arbitration Act as any arbitration with its juridical seat in Mauritius, other than an international arbitration under Section 3(2). ...more
...less
Definition of international arbitration Section 3(2) of the International Arbitration Act 2008 states that for the purposes of subsection (1)(c)(1), an arbitration shall, subject to subsection (6), be an international arbitration where: ...more />
(a) the juridical seat of the arbitration is Mauritius; and
(b)
(i) the parties to the arbitration agreement have, at the time of the conclusion of that agreement, their place of business in different States; or
(ii) one of the following places is situated outside the State in which the parties have their places of business:
(A) the juridical seat of the arbitration if determined in, or pursuant to, the arbitration agreement; or
(B) any place where a substantial part of the obligations of the commercial relationship is to be performed or the place with which the subject matter of the dispute is most closely connected; or
(iii) the parties have expressly agreed that the subject matter of the arbitration agreement relates to more than one State, or that this Act is to apply to their arbitration; or
(iv) the shareholders in a GBL company have determined, pursuant to subsection (6), that any dispute concerning the Constitution of the company or relating to the company shall be referred to arbitration under this Act.
...less
* Are the following types of disputes arbitrable under your country’s national law: (a) Disputes involving rights over immoveable property located within your country: Yes
* (b) Any intra-company disputes( e.g., disputes over decisions made by the executive bodies of a corporation): Yes
* (c) Disputes involving shareholder arrangements: Yes
* (d) Disputes involving patents/trade marks (excluding administrative actions): Yes
(e) Securities transactions: Yes
List any additional commercial matters not listed above which are not arbitrable under your national law: Disputes involving bills of exchange.
* Under your national law, is an arbitration agreement severable from the main contract? No
* Can an arbitration agreement be incorporated by reference? Yes
* Can the following method of concluding an agreement constitute a binding arbitration agreement: (a) by electronic communication, including email Yes
* Can the following method of concluding an agreement constitute a binding arbitration agreement: (b) by fax Yes
* Can the following method of concluding an agreement constitute a binding arbitration agreement: by oral agreement No
* Can the following method of concluding an agreement constitute a binding arbitration agreement: by conduct e.g., performance on the part of one party No
* Has your country ratified the New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards? Yes
* Under national law, are the state and state entities allowed to enter into arbitration with foreign owned companies in connection with the following: (a) Concession agreements Yes
* Under national law, are the state and state entities allowed to enter into arbitration with foreign owned companies in connection with the following: (b) Infrastructure contracts (e.g, construction contracts) Yes
* Under national law, are the state and state entities allowed to enter into arbitration with foreign owned companies in connection with the following: (c) Contracts dealing with natural resources (e.g., contracts dealing with water rights, mining, oil and gas, etc.) Yes
* Under national law, are the state and state entities allowed to enter into arbitration with foreign owned companies in connection with the following: (d) Other types of contracts/transactions (please list all that apply in the “Comments” column) Yes
Comment N/A
* Has your country ratified the ICSID Convention? Yes
** Has your country adopted a specific statute on commercial mediation or conciliation of commercial disputes? No
Comment N/A
Additional comment On question 5 (Under your national law is an arbitration agreement severable from the main contract?):
Although not contained in the statute, the prevailing view is that an arbitration clause is ...more a clause separate from the contract having an autonomous existence. In the case of Tamil Nadu Electricity Board v. ST-CMS Electric Co. Private Ltd [2007] 2 All ER 701, the court held that "an arbitration clause is regarded as a separate arbitration agreement from the rest of the contract obligations between the parties."

On question 7 (Can the following methods of concluding an agreement constitute a binding arbitration agreement: (a) by electronic communication (including email), (b) by fax, (c) by oral agreement, (d) by conduct e.g., performance on the part of one party?):
The Code of Civil Procedure provides that the arbitration clause shall be in writing. Furthermore, the International Arbitration Act also provides in section 4(1)(b) that the arbitration agreement shall be in writing. Section 4 (2) of the International Arbitration Act further point out that "An arbitration agreement is in writing where –
(a) its contents are recorded in any form, whether or not the arbitration agreement or the contract has been concluded orally, by conduct, or by other means;
(b) it is concluded by an electronic communication and the information contained in it is accessible so as to be usable for subsequent reference; or
(c) it is contained in an exchange of statements of claim and defence in which the existence of an agreement is alleged by one party and not denied by the other."
Therefore, if there is no existing arbitration agreement, the parties have to enter into a compromise. Under Article 1008 of the Code of Civil Procedure, the "compromis" is the agreement whereby the parties to the dispute refer each other to arbitration. The compromis should be in written form and can be in the form of signed minutes by the arbitrator and the parties.
...less
* Scored ** Bonus Question
This index compares rules for the arbitration process determining how easy it is for parties to design arbitration proceedings in their chosen manner and conduct fair and predictable arbitrations.
QuestionAnswer
* In a domestic arbitration taking place in your country, may the parties freely choose arbitrators to resolve their dispute without regard to: (a) the arbitrator(s)’ nationality: Yes
* In a domestic arbitration taking place in your country, may the parties freely choose arbitrators to resolve their dispute without regard to: (b) the arbitrator(s)’ gender: Yes
* In a domestic arbitration taking place in your country, may the parties freely choose arbitrators to resolve their dispute without regard to: (c) the arbitrator(s)’ professional qualifications: Yes
* May parties choose to conduct the arbitration proceedings in a foreign language in domestic arbitration? Yes
Comment N/A
* In an international arbitration taking place in your country, may the parties freely choose arbitrators to resolve their dispute without regard to: (a) the arbitrator(s)’ nationality: Yes
* In an international arbitration taking place in your country, may the parties freely choose arbitrators to resolve their dispute without regard to: (b) the arbitrator(s)’ gender: Yes
* In an international arbitration taking place in your country, may the parties freely choose arbitrators to resolve their dispute without regard to: (c) the arbitrator(s)’ professional qualifications: Yes
* May parties choose to conduct the arbitration proceedings in a foreign language in an international arbitration? Yes
Comment N/A
* May the parties freely choose the method of appointing arbitrators to resolve their dispute e.g., by subscribing to arbitration institutional rules in a domestic arbitration? Yes
Comment N/A
* May the parties freely choose the method of appointing arbitrators to resolve their dispute e.g., by subscribing to arbitration institutional rules in an international arbitration? Yes
Comment N/A
* May the parties freely choose the number of arbitrators to resolve their dispute in a domestic arbitration? No
Comment The Mauritius Code of Civil Procedure expressly provides that the number of arbitrators shall be one or in case there are more arbitrators designated, there shall be an odd number of them.
* May the parties freely choose the number of arbitrators to resolve their dispute in an international arbitration? Yes
Comment The International Arbitration Act stipulates that "unless otherwise agreed by the parties there shall be three arbitrators or in case there is a greater number of them, that number shall be an odd on ...moree." ...less
* Does your national law expressly provide that all arbitrators in arbitrations must be independent and impartial in a domestic arbitration? Yes
Does your national law expressly provide that all arbitrators in arbitrations must be independent and impartial in an international arbitration? N/A
* Does your national law expressly provide that all arbitrators in arbitrations must be independent and impartial in an international arbitration? No
Comment Section 13 of the International Arbitration Act states that "an arbitrator may be challenged only if circumstances exist that give rise to justifiable doubts as to his impartiality or independence, o ...morer if he does not possess qualifications agreed to by the parties." ...less
* May each party, if it chooses to do so, retain a foreign lawyer, not licensed to practice in your country, to represent it in an arbitration proceeding in a domestic arbitration No
Comment N/A
* May each party, if it chooses to do so, retain a foreign lawyer, not licensed to practice in your country, to represent it in an arbitration proceeding in an international arbitration Yes
Comment N/A
* Under your national law, are arbitrators expressly bound to preserve confidentiality of arbitration proceedings in a domestic arbitration? No
* Under your national law, are arbitrators expressly bound to preserve confidentiality of arbitration proceedings in an international arbitration? No
* Is online arbitration (or what is sometimes known as electronic Alternative Dispute Resolution) an available method of dispute resolution in your country for domestic arbitrations? No
* Is online arbitration (or what is sometimes known as electronic Alternative Dispute Resolution) an available method of dispute resolution in your country for international arbitrations? No
Comment N/A
* Are parties to an arbitration free to choose any arbitration institution, even one that is outside of your country, to administer their arbitration in a domestic arbitration Yes
* Are parties to an arbitration free to choose any arbitration institution, even one that is outside of your country, to administer their arbitration in an international arbitration Yes
Comment The Code of Civil Procedure provides that the procedures and rules governing the arbitration shall be similar to those of the courts in Mauritius and in case there are any disagreements between the p ...morearties to the dispute in respect of the constitution of the arbitral tribunal, for example, the Code expressly provides that the disputes shall be submitted to and resolved by the judge in Chambers of the Supreme Court of Mauritius. ...less
* Are there any arbitration institutions administering commercial arbitrations in your country? Yes
List the arbitration institutions Permanent Court of Arbitration at Mauritius Chamber of Commerce and Industry - MCCI, which is also a member of the International Federation of Commercial Arbitration Institutions (IFCAI).
* List the arbitration institution's Web sites http://www.mcci.org/
* How long, typically, would you estimate the period to be from the filing of the request for arbitration to the constitution of the arbitration tribunal in a domestic arbitration? Answers: 1=Under 30 days; 2=30-180 days; 3=181 days-1 year; 4=over 1 year 2
* How long, typically, would you estimate the period to be from the filing of the request for arbitration to the constitution of the arbitration tribunal in an international arbitration? Answers: 1=Under 30 days; 2=30-180 days; 3=181 days-1 year; 4=over 1 year 2
* How long, typically, would you estimate the period to be from the first hearing of the arbitration tribunal on the merits to the rendering of the arbitration award In a domestic/ international arbitration in your country? Answers: 1=Under 30 days; 2=30-180 days; 3=181 days-1 year; 4=over 1 year 2
* How long, typically, would you estimate the period to be from the first hearing of the arbitration tribunal on the merits to the rendering of the arbitration award In a domestic/ international arbitration in your country? Answers:1=Under 30 days; 2=30-180 days; 3=181 days-1 year; 4=over 1 year 2
Estimate the number of domestic commercial arbitrations carried out in your country's most commonly used arbitration institution within the past 12 months Answers: 1=0-5 cases; 2=6-20 cases; 3=21-100 cases; 4=101-1000 cases; 5=over 1000 cases; 6=N/A 1
Estimate the number of international commercial arbitrations carried out in your country's most commonly used arbitration institution within the past 12 months Answers: 1=0-5 cases; 2=6-20 cases; 3=21-100 cases; 4=101-1000 cases; 5=over 1000 cases; 6=N/A 1
Comment Such information is not accessible.
* In an arbitration between a foreign owned company and your state or a state entity, can the parties freely choose the seat of arbitration (i.e., seat outside of your country)? Yes
* In an arbitration between a foreign owned company and the state/state entity, can the parties freely choose institutional arbitration or ad hoc arbitration? Yes
* In an arbitration between a foreign owned company and the state/state entity, can the parties freely choose the nationality of the arbitrators? Yes
* In an arbitration between a foreign owned company and the state/state entity, can the parties freely choose foreign counsel? Yes
* In an arbitration between a foreign owned company and the state/state entity, can the parties freely choose the applicable procedural rules? Yes
Are there any other restrictions with respect to party's autonomy in commercial arbitration if one of the parties is the state or a state entity? Yes
Comment N/A
** How often does the state (or state entities) include arbitration clauses in their contracts with foreign companies? Answers: 1=Rarely; 2=Occasionally; 3=Usually; 4=Always or nearly always 3
* Is there a public authority designated to handle administrative, logistical and other issues related to investors’ disputes with the state or a state entity (e.g., specific agency, office of the Prime Minister, etc.)? No
Comment N/A
** How frequently do private parties in your country agree to attempt to settle their commercial disputes through mediation or conciliation? Answers: 1=Rarely; 2=Frequently; 3=Usually; 4=Always or nearly always 2
* Is there an institution (or institutions) in your country that administers the mediation or conciliation of commercial disputes? No
Comment N/A
Have any of the courts in your country adopted mandatory procedures for mediating commercial disputes (e.g., for screening cases and referring to mediation those that appear susceptible of settlement by mediation, or by establishing “multi-door court houses” that enable parties to choose between litigation and mediation of their disputes)? No
Comment N/A
Additional Comment N/A
* Scored ** Bonus Question
This index compares the extent of judicial assistance before, during, and after the arbitration proceedings.
QuestionAnswer
* Have the courts in your country stated a “pro-arbitration policy”, i.e., a general policy in favor of enforcing arbitration agreements and arbitration awards, in applying your national law of arbitration In domestic/international arbitrations taking place in your country? No
Comment The courts have not stated a "pro-arbitration" policy expressly, but subject to all the conditions for an arbitration (domestic and international) being fulfilled, they are generally in favor of enfo ...morercing arbitration agreements and rendering arbitration awards. The International Arbitration Act has been proclaimed on January 1, 2009 and, at this stage, it is not possible to confirm the opinion of the court vis-à-vis that Act. ...less
* If the parties have expressly agreed (i.e., in writing) that the arbitration tribunal can rule on its own jurisdiction, will that be upheld by your national courts? Yes
Comment The court can only intervene to see whether the arbitrator has ousted its jurisdiction by adjudicatng on matters it has not been appointed to adjudicate upon.
* If a party brings an action in a court of your country with respect to a dispute that the parties have previously agreed (in a valid arbitration agreement or other writing) must be arbitrated (either in your country or elsewhere) how frequently would the courts in your country decline to hear the case and refer the parties to arbitration In domestic/international arbitrations taking place in your country? Answers: 1=Rarely; 2=Usually; 3=In all or nearly all cases 3
* If a party brings an action in a court of your country with respect to a dispute that the parties have previously agreed (in a valid arbitration agreement or other writing) must be arbitrated (either in your country or elsewhere) how frequently would the courts in your country decline to hear the case and refer the parties to arbitration in international arbitrations taking place in your country? Answers: 1=Rarely; 2=Usually; 3=In all or nearly all cases 3
Comment This issue is usually left to the respondent party, who has to raise it (as a plea in limine) in his defense.
The court will have to determine whether the arbitration clause has removed the cou ...morert’s jurisdiction altogether from certain matters.
...less
* Does your national law provide for domestic courts to assist the arbitration process by ordering the production of documents or the appearance of witnesses In domestic arbitrations taking place in your country? No
* Does your national law provide for domestic courts to assist the arbitration process by ordering the production of documents or the appearance of witnesses In international arbitrations taking place in your country? Yes
* Are requests for court assistance by ordering the production of documents or the appearance of witnesses generally granted In domestic arbitrations? Yes
* Are requests for court assistance by ordering the production of documents or the appearance of witnesses generally granted in international arbitrations? Yes
Comment N/A
* Does your national law provide for your courts to assist the arbitrators or parties by granting interim relief to prevent immediate and irreparable injury (e.g., preliminary injunctions, the sequestration of property) while the arbitration is pending or before the arbitration has commenced In domestic arbitrations taking place in your country? No
* Does your national law provide for your courts to assist the arbitrators or parties by granting interim relief to prevent immediate and irreparable injury (e.g., preliminary injunctions, the sequestration of property) while the arbitration is pending or before the arbitration has commenced In international arbitrations taking place in your country? Yes
* If an immediate need can be shown, how often do courts grant interim relief requests for assistance? Answers: 1=Rarely; 2=Usually; 3=In all or nearly all cases 3
List the law and article which provide for courts' assistance with interim relief. International Arbitration Act of 2008;
Courts Act;
Code of Civil Procedure.
Comment N/A
Given the amount of the arbitration award ($US100, 000) and the location of the assets (your country's largest business city), what court in your country has jurisdiction to enforce an arbitration award rendered in your country (in domestic or international proceedings)? Supreme Court of Mauritius
** Is the court for enforcement of arbitration awards rendered in your country, a higher level court or a specialized court? Yes
* May a judgment of that court enforcing the award be appealed to a higher court or courts? Yes
May a judgment of that court denying enforcement of the award be appealed to a higher court or courts? Yes
If Yes, indicate the name of the court(s) of appeal The Supreme Court of Mauritius, and ultimately the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council.
* In the case of a domestic award, if a party brings an action in court to set aside (vacate or annul) a domestic arbitration award against it, is the court authorized to review that award on the merits? No
* In the case of an international award, if a party brings an action in court to set aside (vacate or annul) a domestic arbitration award against it, is the court authorized to review that award on the merits? No
Under your national law, can a domestic award rendered in favor of a local company be denied confirmation or enforcement, or be set aside, annulled or vacated, by a court in your country on the following grounds: Invalidity of the underlying arbitration agreement or lack of capacity of a party? Yes
Under your national law, can a domestic award rendered in favor of a local company be denied confirmation or enforcement, or be set aside, annulled or vacated, by a court in your country on the following grounds: Lack of a fair hearing? Yes
Under your national law, can a domestic award rendered in favor of a local company be denied confirmation or enforcement, or be set aside, annulled or vacated, by a court in your country on the following grounds: Award deals with matters outside the scope of the arbitraton agreement? Yes
Under your national law, can a domestic award rendered in favor of a local company be denied confirmation or enforcement, or be set aside, annulled or vacated, by a court in your country on the following grounds: Arbitration procedures not in accordance with the parties' s agreement or the governing arbitration law? Yes
Under your national law, can a domestic award rendered in favor of a local company be denied confirmation or enforcement, or be set aside, annulled or vacated, by a court in your country on the following grounds: Subject matter of the dispute not subject to arbitration? Yes
Under your national law, can a domestic award rendered in favor of a local company be denied confirmation or enforcement, or be set aside, annulled or vacated, by a court in your country on the following grounds: Enforcement of the award would be contrary to country's public policy? Yes
Under your national law, can a domestic award rendered in favor of a local company be denied confirmation or enforcement, or be set aside, annulled or vacated, by a court in your country on the following grounds: Error of law? Yes
Under your national law, can a domestic award rendered in favor of a local company be denied confirmation or enforcement, or be set aside, annulled or vacated, by a court in your country on the following grounds: Award not supported by substantial evidence? Yes
Under your national law, list any additional grounds under which the domestic award rendered in favor of GlobiCo may be denied confirmation or enforcement, or be set aside, annulled or vacated, by a court in your country. The parties have expressly renounced their right of appeal under the agreement, which states that the award of the arbitrator shall be final and conclusive. They are consequently left to a recourse ...morein annulment as provided for in Article 1027-3 which reads as follows: "where, in accordance with the distinctions made in Article 1027-1, the parties abandoned the appeal, or they have not expressly reserved the right to appeal in the arbitration agreement, an action for annulment of the arbitration agreement, an action for annulment of the arbitration award may be made despite any stipulation to the contrary.
It is only applicable in the following cases:
1.1 if the arbitrator has exercised his duty without any agreement or where the arbitration agreement was invalid or expired;
2. if the arbitration tribunal was irregularly composed or the sole arbitrator was irregularly appointed;
3. If the arbitrator ruled without complying with the duty which had been conferred;
4. When the principle of contradiction has not been respected;
5. In all cases of invalidity provided for in Article 1026-5;
6. if the referee has violated any rule of public order."
...less
* What is the likelihood that your courts would enforce a domestic arbitration award if no objection to enforcement were filed? Answers: 1=Rarely; 2=Usually; 3=In all or nearly all cases 3
* What is the likelihood that your courts would enforce an international arbitration award if no objection to enforcement were filed? Answers: 1=Rarely; 2=Usually; 3=In all or nearly all cases 3
* Number of days on average necessary to enforce a domestic and international arbitration award in your country: (a) From the filing of an application for enforcement to the date of a hearing for such an application in the first instance court ? 24
* Number of days on average necessary to enforce a domestic and international arbitration award in your country: (b) From the date of the first hearing to the first instance court decision, if no objection to enforcement has been filed? 30
Number of days on average necessary to enforce a domestic and international arbitration award in your country: (c) From the first instance court decision to the decision of the final court of appeal (assuming that all avenues of appeal were pursued). In the second column, please list all relevant courts of appeal? 120
* Number of days on average necessary to enforce a domestic and international arbitration award in your country: (d) From the final court decision granting enforcement to GlobiCo obtaining a writ of execution attaching Supplier’s assets (e.g. bank account)? 60
Comment The timeframe cannot be specified, since it may vary at any time.
Given the amount of the foreign arbitration award ($US100, 000) and the location of the assets (your countrys' largest business city), what court in your country has jurisdiction to enforce a foreign arbitration award (i.e. an award rendered outside of your country)? Supreme Court of Mauritius
** Is the court for enforcement of arbitration awards rendered outside your country, a higher level court or a specialized court? Yes
* May a judgment of that court enforcing the award or denying enforcement be appealed to a higher court or courts? Yes
If Yes, indicate the name of the court(s) of appeal Decision of the Supreme Court of Mauritius can be appealed to the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council.
Under your national law may an arbitration award rendered in another country be denied recognition or enforcement by your country’s courts on the ground of "invalidity of the underlying arbitration agreement or lack of capacity of a party"? Yes
Under your national law may an arbitration award rendered in another country be denied recognition or enforcement by your country’s courts on the ground of lack of a fair hearing? Yes
Under your national law may an arbitration award rendered in another country be denied recognition or enforcement by your country’s courts on the ground of that the award deals with matters outside the scope of the arbitraton agreement? Yes
Under your national law may an arbitration award rendered in another country be denied recognition or enforcement by your country’s courts on the ground that the arbitration procedures not in accordance with the parties' s agreement or the governing arbitration law? Yes
Under your national law may an arbitration award rendered in another country be denied recognition or enforcement by your country’s courts on the ground that the award was set aside in the country where it was made? Yes
Under your national law may an arbitration award rendered in another country be denied recognition or enforcement by your country’s courts on the ground that the subject matter of the dispute not subject to arbitration? Yes
Under your national law may an arbitration award rendered in another country be denied recognition or enforcement by your country’s courts on the ground of public policy? Yes
* Under your national law may an arbitration award rendered in another country be denied recognition or enforcement by your country’s courts on the ground of "error of law"? Yes
* Under your national law may an arbitration award rendered in another country be denied recognition or enforcement by your country’s courts on the ground of that the award not supported by substantial evidence? Yes
* Under your national law, list additional grounds under which an arbitration award rendered in another country be denied recognition or enforcement by your country’s courts N/A
* What is the likelihood that your courts would enforce a foreign award if no objection to enforcement were filed? Answers: 1=Rarely; 2=Usually; 3=In all or nearly all cases 3
* Number of days on average necessary to enforce a foreign arbitration award in your country: (a) From the filing of an application for enforcement to the date of a hearing for such an application in the first instance court ? 24
* Number of days on average necessary to enforce a foreign arbitration award in your country: (b) From the date of the first hearing to the first instance court decision, if no objection to enforcement has been filed? 21
Number of days on average necessary to enforce a foreign arbitration award in your country: (c) From the first instance court decision to the decision of the final court of appeal (assuming that all avenues of appeal were pursued). In the second column, please list all relevant courts of appeal? 150
* Number of days on average necessary to enforce a foreign arbitration award in your country: (d) From the final court decision granting enforcement to GlobiCo obtaining a writ of execution attaching Supplier’s assets (e.g. bank account)? 30
Comment N/A
* In arbitrations involving a state or state entity, can your court(s) review the arbitration award on its merits in connection with recognition and enforcement proceedings? Yes
Additional Comment N/A
* Scored ** Bonus Question